How do you reply when a prospect says "not interested" or "send me info"?

The short answer

Reply the same day, in three lines or fewer. To "not interested": accept it, ask one easy question about fit or timing, and stop if there's no answer. To "send me info": send one thing, not five, and attach a question that tells you what they care about. And when someone tells you to stop, stop. The FTC's CAN-SPAM guide gives you 10 business days to honor an opt-out and makes no exception for B2B email.

Updated

Which kind of reply did you get?

A reply to a cold email is rare, and even a "no" is a person telling you something. Read it before you answer it. These six cover most of the brush-offs you'll get in writing:

The reply What it usually means Your move
"Not interested." A reflex. They read the first line, maybe One short reply with one question. Then done
"Not interested, we use [vendor]." They gave you a reason, which is a gift Ask one thing about the vendor. Log the name
"Send me some info." Either polite curiosity or a polite exit Send one thing and one question
"Not now. Try me next quarter." Timing, or a softer no Ask what changes, then set the date
"I'm the wrong person." You have a list problem and a free referral Ask who, and whether you can use their name
"Stop emailing me." / "Unsubscribe." A clear instruction Remove them today. No reply needed, or one line

This page is about written replies. For the same objections on a live call, where you have ten seconds and a tone of voice, see cold call objection handling.

What do you write back to "not interested"?

One reply. Three parts: accept, one question, an exit.

Understood, and thanks for telling me. One question so I don't bother you again for the wrong reason: is it that [problem] isn't an issue for your team, or that the timing is off?

Either way, I'll leave you alone.

Why it works: you agreed first, so there's nothing to argue with. The question has two easy answers, and both are useful. "Not an issue" tells you your targeting was off. "Timing" tells you when to come back. And the last line means it. If they don't answer, you're done with this person for this campaign.

If they named a vendor, use it:

Makes sense, [vendor] is a solid choice. Out of curiosity, is there anything your team works around with it? If not, I'll get out of your inbox.

What not to send: a longer pitch, a case study they didn't ask for, "can I ask why?", or a guilt trip. One reply. If you get a second no, you say thanks.

What do you send when they say "send me info"?

Not the deck. Not five links. One thing, in the body of the email, with a question on the end.

Happy to. The short version:

  • [What it does, in one line]
  • [The result one customer like them got, in one line, only if it's true and you can name the source]
  • [What it takes to get started, in one line]

So I send the right detail next: is the bigger issue for you [option A] or [option B]?

Three lines they can read on a phone beat a PDF they'll never open. The question at the end is the real test. Someone who is curious will answer it. Someone who wanted you gone won't, and you've lost nothing.

If they answer, you now know what they care about, and your next email is two lines and a meeting ask. If they don't, follow up once, a few days later, with something new and short. Then let your normal follow-up sequence finish or stop.

What about "not now" and "wrong person"?

"Not now." Don't just say "sure, I'll check back." Ask what changes:

No problem. What changes next quarter: a budget, a hire, a contract ending? I'll note it and come back then, with something relevant instead of a "just checking in."

Their answer is your reason to write again. Put the month and the reason in your CRM. A date without a reason turns into a "just checking in" email, and nobody answers those.

"Wrong person." Two questions in one line:

Thanks, that saves us both time. Who handles [problem] on your team, and is it okay if I mention you pointed me their way?

A name plus permission turns a cold email into a referred one. If you get neither, find the right owner yourself; see how to find the decision maker. If "wrong person" keeps coming back, the problem is the list, not the copy.

How fast should you reply?

Same working day. Our guidance: within the hour when you can.

There's no good public study on reply speed for cold email responses. The closest evidence is about inbound web leads: a Harvard Business Review study of 1.25 million leads found that companies that tried to make contact within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to qualify the lead as those that waited one more hour. A reply to your cold email is a smaller signal than a web form, so don't treat that number as yours. The logic carries over, though: they're thinking about you right now, and tomorrow they won't be.

Two habits make speed possible:

  • Write your replies before you need them. Keep the four replies above as saved snippets and edit the brackets. A reply you have to compose from scratch waits until tonight.
  • Check replies at fixed times. Twice in the morning, twice in the afternoon. A sequencer inbox nobody opens until Friday turns every reply into a cold one.

When do you stop?

  • One reply to a "no." If your one question gets no answer, the conversation is over. Pull them from the sequence so step 4 doesn't land three days later and undo your polite exit.
  • "Stop" means today. Remove the address from the sequence, mark it do-not-contact in the CRM, and make sure a teammate's campaign can't pick it up next month. US law gives you 10 business days under CAN-SPAM. Don't use them. Other countries are stricter, so check the rules where your prospects are.
  • Angry replies get no argument. Remove, don't respond, or send one line: "Done. You won't hear from us again."

Every "stop" you ignore is a possible spam complaint, and those cost you far more than one lost prospect. See what spam complaint rate is too high.

What should you log?

Tag every reply with its type. It takes five seconds and it's the cheapest research you'll ever do.

Example (made-up numbers): over a month you get 40 replies to one campaign.

Reply type Count Share
Not interested 22 55%
Send me info 9 22.5%
Not now 5 12.5%
Wrong person 4 10%

What it tells you: four "wrong person" replies in 40 means one in ten of your replies comes from a bad title. Fix the list before you touch the copy. Nine "send me info" replies are nine people who didn't say no. Did all nine get a same-day answer?

None of these count as positive replies. Keep them out of that number, or you'll fool yourself about what's working; see reply rate vs positive reply rate vs meeting rate.

Sources

Pages accessed October 4, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Should I reply to "not interested" at all?

Yes, once. Accept it and ask one easy question about fit or timing. If they don't answer, stop. A second push can turn a neutral no into a spam complaint.

What should I send when a prospect asks for more information?

Three short lines in the body of the email and one question about what matters to them. Skip the deck and the link list. The question tells you whether they're curious or just being polite.

How quickly should I answer a reply to a cold email?

The same working day, and within the hour when you can. That's our guidance. The best public research is on inbound leads, not cold email replies, so there's no benchmark to quote.

Do I have to stop emailing someone who says "not interested"?

Treat it as the end of that campaign. If the reply reads like a request to stop, honor it as one: the FTC's CAN-SPAM guide says an opt-out must be honored within 10 business days, and B2B email is covered. We're not lawyers, so check the rules where your prospects are.

Is a "send me info" reply a positive reply?

Not yet. Count it as neutral until they answer your follow-up question or accept a meeting. Counting it as positive inflates your numbers.

Keep reading